Project

Truth After Tazmamart

A deck-first research project on Morocco's Equity and Reconciliation Commission, the Years of Lead, and the political logic of transitional justice without punishment.

My role, areas & skills

Role
Historical researcher, legal analyst, and documentary storyteller
Areas
Research / Public Scholarship
Skills
Human rights history, International law, Transitional justice, Morocco, Public scholarship

The objective

Examine what truth-seeking can achieve when a transitional justice process limits punishment and accountability.

What I did

Synthesized historical and legal research on Tazmamart and Morocco’s Equity and Reconciliation Commission.
Built a written analysis and slide narrative explaining the political limits of reconciliation.

Deliverables

Truth After Tazmamart research paper.
Presentation deck and rendered slides.

Result

Produced a paper and presentation that make the argument and supporting material available for readers.

The deck

Truth After Tazmamart presentation

Download the full deck (PDF) →

Use the controls to browse 20 slides. Select an image for a larger view, or open the PDF.

Read extracted slide text

Text extracted from the original PDF. Image-only slides and visual relationships are not fully represented here; consult the slide image and the written project narrative.

Slide 1

Reese W. Hollister Master of International Studies ‘26 PS 531: International Law Dr. Michael Struett Truth after Tazmamart: Lawfulness in Morocco’s Equality & Reconciliation Commission

Slide 2

“How can a legal system restore respect for law and justice after the collapse of a regime that respected neither?” - Lon L. Fuller

Slide 3

‫ﺳﻨﻮات اﻟﺮﺻﺎص‬ -- The Years of Lead Early 1960s - Early 1990s

Slide 4

‫ھﯿﺌﺔ اﻹﻧﺼﺎف واﻟﻤﺼﺎﻟﺤﺔ‬ Equity & Reconciliation Commission (ERC) 2004 - 2005

Slide 5

Why did the ERC not name or punish perpetrators when international norms shifted towards individual accountability for human rights violations?

Slide 6

I argue that the Equity and Reconciliation Commission signiﬁcantly reduced threats against the monarchy during the Arab Spring precisely because the ERC did not punish perpetrators.

Slide 7

The Years of Lead

Slide 8

King Hassan II r. 1961 - 1999 “The Great Survivor” - Al-Makhzan - 1965 Casablanca Riots - 1971 Skhirat Palace Attack - 1972 Coup d’Etat Attempt Response: Political Repression - Forced Disappearance - Torture in Illegal Prisons - Wrongful Imprisonment

Slide 9

This slide contains an image or diagram without extractable text. Open its full-size image above.

Slide 10

The Years of Lead in Everyday Life Gross Violations Political Everyday of Human Rights Repression Corruption In 1964, 18 men who In 1965, General Mohamed A youth with no powerful smuggled arms in from Oufkir, the new interior connections to protect him Algeria were sentenced to minister, repressed rioting in may be forced to sign a police report and spend death and executed in Casablanca, and tolls are months in jail for a crime he military tribunals. estimated to be around 50 didn't commit. dead and 200 injured. (Hughes, 2001, 123) (Hughes, 2001, 130) (Moukhlis, 2008, 358)

Slide 11

Individual Accountability

Slide 12

Individual Accountability in International Law 1945: Nuremberg Trials Precedent 1984: UN Convention Against Torture 1998: Pinochet Case 1998: International Criminal Court (ICC)

Slide 13

Why did the ERC not name or punish perpetrators when international norms shifted towards individual accountability for human rights violations?

Slide 14

Legal Legitimacy

Slide 15

The Equity and Reconciliation Commission (ERC) Mandate: “to assess, research, investigate, arbitrate and make recommendations about the gross human rights violations that occurred between 1956 and the end of 1999.” Oral Testimony - Varying levels of cooperation - Public hearings were limited - Archives were deplorable Accordance with International Law

Slide 16

This slide contains an image or diagram without extractable text. Open its full-size image above.

Slide 17

Risking Political Consequences

Slide 18

King Mohammed VI in the 21st Century 1999: Death of King Hassan II Start of Mohammed VI’s Reign 2004-2005: Equity & Reconciliation Commission 2011: Morocco’s “Arab” Spring Constitutional Reforms “Unity in Diversity” - ‫اﻟوﺣدة ﻓﻲ اﻟﺗﻧوع‬ “Its unity, is forged by the convergence of its Arab-Islamist, Berber/Amazigh and Saharan-Hassanic components, nourished and enriched by its African, Andalusian, Hebraic and Mediterranean inﬂuences.”

Slide 19

This slide contains an image or diagram without extractable text. Open its full-size image above.

Slide 20

Shukran! Tanmirt! Merci! Thank You! Do you have any questions? rwhollis@ncsu.edu https://sites.google.com/ncsu.edu/reese https://www.youtube.com/@HistoricalMethodMan CREDITS: This presentation template was created by Slidesgo, and includes icons by Flaticon, and infographics & images by Freepik

Written paper

Overview

Truth After Tazmamart asks why Morocco's Equity and Reconciliation Commission did not name or punish perpetrators after the Years of Lead, even as international human-rights norms moved toward individual accountability.

The project treats that decision as a legal and political problem: not simply a failure to punish, but a choice about how far a monarchy-led truth process could go while preserving state legitimacy.

What the deck shows

The deck introduces the Years of Lead, Tazmamart as a symbol of secret detention and state violence, the rise of international accountability norms, and the ERC mandate in 2004-2005.

It then frames the central argument: the ERC reduced pressure on the monarchy partly because it pursued public truth, compensation, and institutional repair without directly prosecuting perpetrators.

Why it matters

The project sits at the intersection of Moroccan history, international law, and public memory. It shows how transitional justice can produce real testimony and recognition while also protecting the political structures that shaped the violence.